Updated: Jun 15
It’s that time of the year again: A combination of New Year’s resolutions and tax time has many of us looking for a place to donate money. It can be difficult to figure out which charity is most deserving of your money and how to make your charitable donations work best for your financial situation.
You might have a favorite charity, like a local group or someone with whom you’ve worked for years. If not, finding the right charity can be a difficult task, both because unethical individuals may want to exploit the best intentions of others and because running a nonprofit organization is a difficult task, making many well-intentioned charities ineffective at fulfilling their mission.
Check out the charity with an objective watchdog group
The best way to determine whether a charity is a good organization and worthy of your donation is to check with the three biggest charity watchdog organizations: Charity Navigator, Charity Watch and the Better Business Bureau’s Wise Giving Alliance, all of which are also endorsed by Consumer Reports.
Verify each charity’s tax-exempt status
Never assume an organization has tax-exempt status, even if it might seem like it does or should. For example, some universities offer tax-exempt donations for their general scholarship funds and other donations, but giving to specific departments or organizations, such as the debate team or theater department, is not tax-exempt. Even if your donation was tax-exempt last year, even if someone involved in the organization tells you that they’re tax-exempt, even if you’re 99% sure the organization is tax-exempt, check with the IRS website.
Always give money directly
One way that scammers will use the goodwill of charities for their own benefit is to call people and ask for donations over the phone. Don’t assume that someone who calls you actually works for the organization. Instead, finish your conversation and then donate directly to the organization. Even legitimate fundraisers often take 40% of the proceeds, keeping your money from the people you really want to help.
Donating directly also gives you more control over the paperwork, ensuring you get all the documents you need for a tax deduction. You can also confirm the quality of the organization and that the organization is tax-exempt.
Make sure to request privacy
Once you’ve given money to a charity, it’s easy to end up on countless lists with people calling constantly from other charities. If you’ve ever given money to a political campaign, you’ve probably already experienced this. Some of our members report that they’ve received correspondence from political parties for decades, even after switching political parties. So be careful! Make sure you care enough about the charity that it won’t bother you to have your dinner interrupted or get junk mail.